Should Pirates Pursue Carlos Pena?

By: Mike Vukovcan

Pittsburgh (KDKA)- The Pirates front office got a first hand look at Chicago Cubs first baseman Carlos Pena over the weekend.

The question now is will GM Neal Huntington attempt to trade for him?

The 33-year-old is a classic power hitter. He hits a ton of home runs but also strikes out a bunch.

Here are his stats over the last few years:
2010 w/Tampa Bay: 28 HR’s and 84 RBI (158 K’s in 484 at-bats)
2009 w/Tampa Bay: 39 HR’s and 100 RBI (163 K’s in 471 at-bats)

2008 w/Tampa Bay: 31 HR’s and 102 RBI (166 K’s in 490 at-bats)

2007 w/Tampa Bay: 46 HR’s and 121 RBI (142 K’s in 490 at-bats)

In 340 at-bats with Chicago, Pena has hit 19 home runs.

Money could be a potential drawback with the Pirates trading for Pena. According to, “the Cubs were short on payroll space when they signed Pena, and authored a fairly unique one-year deal that deferred half of his salary until January of 2012. That means an acquiring team would owe Pena around $1.6MM for the remainder of the season if they acquire him at the deadline, but then would have to tack another $5MM for him onto their 2012 payroll.”

Would Pirates owner Bob Nutting approve such a trade?

In terms of draft pick compensation, Pena projects as a Type B free agent.


One Comment

  1. Anonymous says:

    why he bats 220 to 230 put jones at first and presley in right

    1. Anonymous says:

      jones is only hitting 248 he hit 6 hrs in the first month and 2 since pena hit 2 in the first month and about 17 since the pirates need a power bat and a good defender at first base which lyle overbay isnt and pedro is struggling to drive in runs

  2. VukovcanStinks says:

    Mike Vukovcan is total moron.

  3. Jim says:

    While Pena strikes out a lot and has a low batting average, he also takes a lot of walks. Carlos has a higher OBP than a lot of the .300 hitters. This also means that he sees a lot of pitches and works deep counts that could end in a strikeout or walk, but puts a workload on the pitcher. I think he could make sense for the Pirates.

  4. Matt says:

    Better than Lyle OVERPAID!

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Pittsburgh

Play It
Get The All New CBS Local App

Watch & Listen LIVE