Shea-ved Ice: Putting Asham-Beagle Fight To Sleep

By: Casey Shea

It has taken me a couple of days to filter through what has been said and organize my thoughts on “The Fight.”

If this comes across in a “Get off my lawn,” tone, I apologize, but some things just need to be said.

It amazes me how one fight has set the hockey world on fire.

Let’s set the scene, shall we?

The Penguins were down 2-1 in the third period of Thursday’s game against the Washington Capitals.

Washington’s Jay Beagle got into a minor shoving match with Kris Letang and ripped the defenseman’s helmet off of his head.

Arron Asham saw it and skated over to Beagle to tell him to think twice about doing it again.

According to Asham, Beagle challenged him and he obliged. Two punches later, the fight was over and the Internet exploded over Asham’s go to sleep motion en route to the penalty box.

Asham called it a classless move on his part and apologized as such.

The thing is, it’s not all that rare to see someone gesture to the crowd after winning a fight. (Here’s a few from Dan Carcillo.)

However, I can see where people would have an issue with the particular one Asham employed.

In my opinion, the outcry over it is completely absurd and it has nothing to do with it being a Capital being on the wrong end of things. If it was a Penguin who got knocked out, I’d still be writing this.

Side note: the last three games I’ve gone to at CONSOL Energy Center, Colton Orr got knocked out by Deryk Engelland, Rick DiPietro was dropped by Brent Johnson and now Asham beat Beagle.

A major factor in everyone taking notice of this is because it was a game between the Capitals and Penguins.

Would I be annoyed if an opposing player made the same gesture after a fight? Sure, but let’s not go off the deep end and start trying to draw false conclusions between unrelated discussions.

What I found particularly unsettling in the aftermath was some writers out there trying to lump fighting and headshots into one discussion.

The last time I checked, in a fight you willingly engage with your opponent knowing the risk of injury is one punch away.

A headshot is what the league is cracking down on in terms of hitting. Direct blows to the head while trying to deliver a check are the issue.

To clarify, checking and fighting are two entirely different issues at the forefront of the NHL at this time. Trying to link them together is utter nonsense.

Like it or not, fighting is a part of the game. However, incidents like this one bring the anti-fighting contingent out of the woodwork.

Somewhat lost in all of this is Alex Ovechkin criticizing Asham for taking on an inexperienced fighter.

Would Ovechkin have felt better about watching a teammate get dropped if Pascal Dupuis, Ben Lovejoy or some other “inexperienced” Penguin had done it?

Will Ovechkin be the first guy in line to challenge Asham when the two teams meet again on Dec. 1?

I wouldn’t put money on it considering Ovechkin only has two regular season fights to his credit according to

Even if this did happen, would Ovechking continue to criticize Asham for taking on inexperienced fighters? It would be one thing if Matt Hendricks had been calling out Asham.

We also don’t need to bring up the embarrassing 50th goal celebration Ovechkin displayed in 2009 do we?

Also, if Asham was really such a bad guy, would he have gently let Beagle fall to the ice?

After the second punch, Beagle was out on his feet. Had Asham just let go of the jersey, Beagle would have slammed his face against the ice, which could have caused even more damage.

Instead, Asham guided him to the ice and skated away knowing the fight was over.

You never want to see a guy get hurt and it’s unfortunate Beagle went down that hard, but let’s just put this issue to bed already.

You can follow me on Twitter at

For More Penguins Coverage Check Out Puck Talk With Popchock.


More Shea-ved Ice Blog
More Sports News

More Penguins News
Pittsburgh Penguins

  • Devil's Advocate

    Typical “Homer” response, I will guarentee that if this situation was reversed and Crosby was the one knocked out, this town would be crying for the culprit to be taken out back of the arena and shot. Nice try though!

  • pens fan

    If you watched the fight,it was beagle who threw the first four or five punches,He could have held on and covered up or “turtled up ” at any time.He was a willing opponent and got what he got. Ovechkin should keep his mouth shut,He’s alway trying to run unsuspecting player and end their seasons, Hes a hard player ,but as dirty as they come

  • Ben

    It’s amazing how you took what other good writers are saying about Asham’s antics and twisted them around.

    Fighting belongs in hockey and should never be removed but what he did after the fight was tasteless and very unprofessional…that’s what the other writers are talking about. He should be suspended for his unprofessional actions. This isn’t the UFC or MMA…If he wants to act like that they he shouldn’t be playing hockey. Your reference to Carcillo…Really? You just sent me to a video of good hockey fights and nothing more. Not once did I see Carcillo act as childish or immature as Asham did.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Bringing You The Best in Sports Talk Radio
Download And Win Today!

Listen Live