Investigation Shows Consumers Don’t Always Get Fish They Pay For

PITTSBURGH (KDKA) — Americans spent more than $80 billion on seafood last year.

That’s up five billion from the year before, but Consumer Reports’ just-released investigation shows people aren’t always getting the fish they’re paying for.

Investigators sent out secret shoppers to get samples for testing.

“Our secret shoppers bought 190 samples of 14 different kinds of fish – red snapper, salmon, sole and others,” said Consumer Reports’ Kim Kleman. “They went to more than 50 retail stores and restaurants in New York, New Jersey and Connecticut.”

Consumer Reports testers packed pieces from each sample and sent them off to an outside lab.

DNA testing technicians extracted DNA from each sample to determine what kind of fish it was. The results? Only four of the 14 types of fish bought were always identified correctly.

Click here to see the full report.

The biggest discrepancy? Lemon sole. Of the 10 samples, not one turned out to be lemon sole.

The red snapper purchases also proved problematic. Of the 22 samples, only 10 were actually red snapper.

“Fish passes through so many hands from the time it’s caught to the time it’s sold that it’s hard to tell where the mislabeling occurs, or whether it’s intentional,” said Kleman. “That makes the process very difficult to police.”

Consumer Reports findings are in line with other recent studies that show some 20 to 25 percent of seafood around the world is mislabeled.

But unfortunately, until seafood can be more closely monitored, there really is no way to be sure you’re getting what you’re paying for.

Current legislation in the Senate would strengthen cooperation among the different federal agencies that oversee seafood safety, including the Food and Drug Administration, an idea Consumer Reports supports.

Consumer Reports
Consumer Reports: “Mystery fish”
More Consumer Reports
More Consumer News

More from Susan Koeppen

One Comment

  1. Freddy says:

    Sounds fishy to me, why does anyone care?

  2. Ernie J. says:

    Another half fillied story. What fish were substituted for the lemon sole and red snapper?

  3. It's Me says:

    Why is it the Feds want a hand in everything, yet always make matters worse?

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Pittsburgh

Play It
Get The All New CBS Local App

Watch & Listen LIVE