UPMC: Tax Exempt Status Challenge Should Be Dismissed

(Photo Credit: KDKA)

(Photo Credit: KDKA)

(Photo: KDKA-TV) Christine D'Antonio
Christine D’Antonio joined the KDKA-TV news team as a general...
Read More

PITTSBURGH (KDKA) — It didn’t take long for UPMC to ask a federal judge to toss out Mayor Ravenstahl’s lawsuit against the health giant.

Just a week after the case was transferred from state to federal court, UPMC says the case should be dismissed altogether.

In an 11-page motion, UPMC claims the city did not follow the proper procedure to challenge its tax exempt status:

Statement from UPMC:

“[The city’s lawsuit is] a targeted attack against UPMC [which] deliberately circumvented the entire administrative process required for the assessment and collection of city payroll taxes.”

The legal wrangling began a month ago when Mayor Ravenstahl charged that UPMC it is not a purely public charity, does less than it should as a non-profit, and does not qualify for tax exemption under the Pennsylvania’s so-called HUP test.

“When they had revenues of over $5.7 billion dollars– to give less than two-percent back to my community is in my mind a clear failure of meeting one of the prongs of that HUP test,” Mayor Ravenstahl says.

It’s a claim strongly rejected by UPMC.

“We easily meet all five criteria for our tax exempt status.  There’s no question,” says UPMC spokesman Paul Wood. “We contributed last year $622 million dollars in charity care and other charitable contributions to organizations in the city, Allegheny County, and around the region.


More Local News

More Latest News

More Christine D’Antonio Reports