High Court Strikes Down Casino Payments To Host Communities

HARRISBURG, Pa. (KDKA/AP) – Pennsylvania’s highest court on Wednesday struck down a requirement that has forced casinos to pay tens of millions of dollars to their host communities for a decade, potentially dealing a crippling blow to local budgets around the state if lawmakers do not act quickly.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that the roughly 4 percent “local share assessment” is unconstitutional because it is not uniform and affects Pennsylvania’s 12 casinos differently.

The justices said they would delay the effect of their decision striking down the tax for four months to give lawmakers an opportunity to fix it.

“We are mindful that our decision may significantly affect many counties and municipalities that have ordered their affairs in reliance upon” the casino tax revenue, Justice David Wecht wrote in the 18-page opinion.

Under the state’s original 2004 casino law, casinos must pay at least 4 percent of gross slot-machine gambling revenues to their host communities. That includes 2 percent to counties and 2 percent or $10 million, whichever is greater, to municipalities.

Regarding the ruling, Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto’s office released the following statement:

“We have our lawyers reviewing the court’s opinion, and have already started working with our legislative delegation to preserve the commitment the casino made to the residents of the city as a condition of the issuance of the license.”

Rivers Casino has been open here in Pittsburgh since 2009. In that time, they’ve paid the City of Pittsburgh approximately $65 million.

SugarHouse Casino in Philadelphia is exempt, as are two smaller “resort” casinos: Valley Forge Casino in suburban Philadelphia and Lady Luck Casino Nemacolin in southwestern Pennsylvania.

But Mount Airy Casino in northeastern Pennsylvania’s Pocono Mountains had asked the court to strike down the $10 million host fee, arguing that it violates the state constitution by imposing a heavier tax burden on lower performing casinos.

Last year, Rivers Casino also filed a lawsuit against the Department of Revenue, though they dropped it a few weeks later.

Some $141 million in slots revenue was paid in the last fiscal year to counties and municipalities, according to Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board data. That included about $48 million paid by casinos to satisfy the $10 million host fee requirement.

Gov. Tom Wolf’s office declined comment on the ruling Wednesday. Senate officials said the decision could have far-reaching effects.

“We will take action and we’ll do it in such a way to maintain the casino obligation to our local communities,” Senate Appropriations Committee Chairman Patrick Browne, R-Lehigh, told the Morning Call of Allentown. “This would absolutely devastate these towns.”

Douglas Hill, executive director of the County Commissioners Association of Pennsylvania, said the money is significant for counties.

“Very clearly, the gaming revenue has gone to legitimate and worthwhile local purposes, all aimed at improving the community, and equally for the host municipalities,” Hill said.

The amount of the host fee is equivalent to the cost of 100 police officers, Bethlehem Mayor Robert Donchez told the Morning Call.

“So this is something that we’re very concerned about,” Donchez said.

The court also awarded relief to Mount Airy Casino, although the amount was not immediately clear.

Join The Conversation On The KDKA Facebook Page
Stay Up To Date, Follow KDKA On Twitter

(TM and © Copyright 2016 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2016 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)

More from Lisa Washington

One Comment

  1. John Dole says:

    Wait, what? So it’s ruled UNCONSTITUTIONAL, yet they can keep doing it for four months while they find another way to create a tax? If it’s UNCONSTITUTIONAL, it should be stopped IMMEDIATELY. Nothing like the government making rules in their own favor.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Pittsburgh

Bringing You The Best in Sports Talk Radio
New Podcast Network
Learn How

Listen Live