Tale Of The Tape: Best Pittsburgh Athletes Of 2015

Chris Mueller
Joe Starkey
(Photo Credit: Abbey Way/93.7 The Fan)
Credit: Pittsburgh Pirates
1st Round
Winner Andrew McCutchen - "A guy whose excellence almost flies under the radar at time."
Jung Ho Kang - "I'm not necessarily going with the best athletes, I'm picking the guy that I enjoyed watching the most."
2nd Round
J.A. Happ - "The guy was basically Roger Clemens during his time with the Pirates."
Winner Antonio Brown - "Chris has called him the Jerry Rice of this generation!"
3rd Round
Winner Cam Heyward - "He had as solid of a year as any Pittsburgh sports athlete."
Jordan Whitehead - "A guy that I absolutely loved watching."
4th Round
Mike Mitchell - "Based on how polarizing he is and the way he crushes opponents."
Winner Tony Watson - "I don't think there was anyone, maybe in all of sports, that quietly handles business the way he does."
5th Round
Winner Ben Roethlisberger - "Has had a phenomenal season in the games he has played."
Bobby Farnham - "He'll fight anyone and defend everyone on my team."
6th Round
Winner Clint Hurdle - The only coach who hasn't failed miserably
Mike Johnston - "He won one more playoff game than Clint Hurdle last year."

The Winner Is

Winner Chris Mueller
4 out of 6

Mueller takes this one by the slimmest of margins, but we appreciate Starkey's reasoning for picking Johnston.


  1. Week 7 Tale Of The Tape: Washington Redskins At Philadelphia Eagles

    The Eagles got the better of Washington the first time these two teams played, the Redskins look to return the favor on the road this week in Philly.

  2. Week 7 Tale Of The Tape: Atlanta Falcons At New England Patriots

    A Super Bowl rematch at Gillette Stadium with the Falcons looking to exact some revenge.

  3. Week 7 Tale Of The Tape: Seattle Seahawks At New York Giants

    The Seahawks come off a bye to a match-up with a Giants team coming off their first win.

See All Tales of the Tape

More From CBS Pittsburgh

Get The All New CBS Local App
KDKA Weather App
Find Cheaper Gas

Watch & Listen LIVE