Best Ice Cream In Pittsburgh

July 9, 2011 10:50 AM

View Comments
credit: Mark Kolbe/Getty Images

credit: Mark Kolbe/Getty Images

Ah, ice cream. It doesn’t have to be a hot summer day to head to your favorite creamery for a scoop of your favorite flavor or a cone of twist soft serve. There are plenty of chain places around town, but here are some of our favorite local places.

98282961 Best Ice Cream In Pittsburgh

credit: Mark Kolbe/Getty Images

Penn-Gold Ice Cream Factory

540 S. Main St.
Harrisville, PA
(724) 735-2121

Pittsburgh Magazine named Penn-Gold Ice Cream Factory “the best place to get an ice cream cone that will suit you to a Tea(berry) in its “Best of the ‘Burgh 2010” feature. That classic, original flavor actually originated here in Pittsburgh – in the form of chewing gum. This place has the flavor down to a science, and they have been in business since 1928.

Dave and Andy’s Homemade Ice Cream

207 Atwood Street
Pittsburgh, PA
(412) 681-9906

Fans of Dave and Andy’s rave about their homemade, unique flavors, like malted ice cream, birthday cake and pumpkin pie. There are plenty of options to please every palate, including low-fat versions for people who want to splurge, but are watching their figure. One KDKA staffer calls this place, “delightful.”

Sarris Candies

511 Adams Avenue
Canonsburg, PA 15317

While most people know Sarris Candies for their wonderful, chocolate-y confections, they also have an old-fashioned ice cream parlor that’s famous for its milkshakes. They’re served in a souvenir cup that you can take home with you. As for the décor, the parlor is a unique mix of opulent decorations – like chandeliers and gold trimmings – and Steelers memorabilia. One KDKA staffer says, “There is so much to choose from, and once you’re done with the ice cream, you can visit the chocolate shop, too.”

Sugar & Spice Ice Cream Parlor

5200 Clairton Blvd
Pittsburgh, PA 15236
(412) 882-7326

If you’re looking for a retro-style soda fountain, this is it. One KDKA staffer says, “Old-fashioned look inside, and some creative treats!” In addition to their fabulous ice cream, Sugar & Spice also stocks cake and candy supplies for home-bakers.

Elly’s Soft Serve

10114 Saltsburg Rd.
Plum, PA
(412) 793-3135

Soft serve fanatics will feel right at home at Elly’s Soft Serve. This mom-and-pop store sells about 20 flavors of soft serve with all the fixin’s. One KDKA staff member says, “It’s a decades-old, family-owned diamond in the rough.”

Cranberry Creamery

20635 Route 19
Cranberry Twp, PA 16066
(724) 742-1313

This little ice cream shack always has a line in the summer – a sign of a real winner. Their ice cream is handmade on site each morning. There is even a drive-up window if you don’t feel like getting out of your car. One KDKA staffer says, “The best homemade ice cream around.” Another adds, “Really cheap and really good! They dip waffle cones in chocolate and put toppings on the cone.”

Valley Dairy

229 Colony Lane
Suite 400
Latrobe, PA 15650
(724) 539-0901

With a dozen locations throughout the Pittsburgh area, the Valley Dairy has sweet treats and fantastic food. The ice cream is homemade. Don’t feel like eating it there? You can buy some to take home too. One KDKA staffer says, “The dessert is one of a kind. Ice cream Joe has an extensive list of homemade ice creams.”

Glen’s Custard Shop

400 Pittsburgh Street
Springdale, PA 15144

Open since 1948, Glen’s Frozen Custard is still pleasing customers with its fine ingredients and homemade custard cakes. The staff tries to add new menu items every year. Want a little entertainment with your ice cream? You can play mini-golf at this ice cream shop too. One KDKA staff member says, “Try it. Only then will you have tasted the very best.”

King Cones Castle

566 Evans City Road
Butler, PA 16001
(724) 482-4909

Locals affectionately call this ice cream shop “The Cow” because of its cow-print exterior and cow statues out front. If you’re looking for quality, affordable ice cream, this is the place to go. Their large menu includes dozens of classic and soft-serve flavors, including unique treats like Root Beer, Cheesecake, Mint Moosetracks and Playdough (always a hit with the kids). The portions are huge for the price. One KDKA staff member says, “It’s easy to treat a family of four to ice cream for about ten dollars.”


311 Beverly Rd
Mt. Lebanon, PA
(412) 561-1994

Patrons of this ice cream shop love the friendly, prompt service and the unique atmosphere. They have several different flavors, making it a local favorite. It’s a great place to take the kids; the prices are low and the quality of the ice cream is fantastic. One KDKA staffer says, “The kids love the flavors!”

Cold Stone Creamery (Honorable Mention)

Various locations nationwide

Best known for its unique mix-in flavors, the Cold Stone Creamery is always a hit. KDKA staffers love that you can add whatever you want to your ice cream, making it your own unique flavor.

View Comments
  • Christine

    You need to check out Katie’s Corner in Grove City. All homemade ice cream and waffle cones. Yum!

  • Rebecca Ashley Conley

    you definitely have to include Page’s ice cream located on the intersection of becks run roads and east carson street.

    • Cj

      Pages is the BEST

  • Susan McIlrath

    How about Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream in West Mifflin and there is also one in Chippewa……. It is really great ice cream.

    • Carol

      They have fabulous ice cream, I agree totally!! We love going there on a warm summer evening, sitting outside eating it. Unfortunately, it isn’t good to make a habit of it, since I lost 50 lbs. LOL

  • Dan

    Hughes ice cream in Harrisville which is by slippery rock… unreal

    • Maggie

      Hughes Ice Cream is actually Penn Gold Ice Cream Factory – the first location listed in the article.

      And I agree, their ice cream is out of this world delicious!

  • Green

    Forbush Drive-In…New Caslte, PA

  • Anonymous

    Speedy’s in Ford City. =)

  • Lek

    Punks in Baden!!!

  • Anonymous

    Earl’s Dairy Whip on Clay Pike

    • Anonymous

      1061 Clay Pike North Huntingdon Pa…

  • swin

    Notice there isn’t a single grocery store ice cream on the list. Oh how we long for the days of good old Isaly’s – they will never be replaced.

  • Sally

    What about Klavon’s in the strip? It’s an old timey ice cream parlor and soda fountain!

  • Chipped Ham

    I think there is an Isaly’s on East Ohio Street on the Northside. It is not in Pittsburgh but The Creamery at Penn State University has excellent ice cream.

  • Klosed Klavon's

    Wanted to try Klavon’s but it never seems to be open. According to their website They sell Reinhold’s, not their own homemade.

  • Kosela

    Baden Punks is the best.

  • Joe

    this must be a very old article… Elly’s ice cream closed about 2 years ago

  • johnny69

    Kerbers Dairy Barn in Irwin…great ice cream, but the best, and I mean the BEST chocolate milk that yiou have ever tasted

  • Anonymous

    Difiores Ice Cream in Mt. washington is by far the best in Pittsburgh!

  • anonymous

    Jordan’s soft serve ice cream on Rte. 268 just north of Kittanning, Pa is the best and most for the money.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Bringing You The Best in Sports Talk Radio
Download And Win Today!

Listen Live