KDKA 2 - Station Info KDKA News Radio 1020 - Station Info 93-7 The Fan - Station Info Pittsburgh-CW-Logo

Latest News

National Anthem Suggestion Stirs Controversy Among High School Hockey Community

View Comments
(Photo Credit: KDKA)

(Photo Credit: KDKA)

John Shumway

Reporting John Shumway

PITTSBURGH (KDKA) — It is a controversial move by the organization that oversees local high school hockey.

With ice time so expensive, and in order to keep the games running on time, the league commissioner has suggested doing away with the National Anthem. And the resulting backlash has been fierce.

Playing the National Anthem is as much a part of sporting events as hot dogs and yelling at the officials.

But PIHL Commissioner Ed Sam sent out an email to the 183 high school teams in Central and Western Pennsylvania saying the singing of the National Anthem is not permitted.

“The National Anthem should not be played only because of time constrains,” said Sam. “It’s not that we’re not patriotic, that’s the furthest from the truth.”

High school hockey must rent the ice time, so every game is carefully timed to get as many in as possible in the shortest amount of time.

“Ice is very, very hard to get and it’s not cheap,” said Sam. “We’re talking $300 an hour sometimes or even higher than that.”

So, when the time for a game is up, play is stopped even if the game is running over because of an over verbose singing of the National Anthem, which happened recently.

“No, they should just extend the time period they have to play the game,” said Melanie Chakrabarti, of Murrysville.

“I don’t agree with it. There should be some other time that can be cut,” added Beth Spena, of Irwin.

Commissioner Sam points out teams aren’t prohibited from playing the Anthem, just discouraged.

“I go back to the 1960s with high school hockey, and it’s always been a part of it,” said Bob Mock, the skating director at Center Ice. “A part of our history, and it should be a part of the game.”

Mock suggests a pre-recorded standardized minute and a half version for all games.

The story isn’t over though; Sam says because of the backlash they’ve been getting, they’re going to have another meeting. They’re going to talk about it and see if they can make some adjustments to put the Nation Anthem back into the games.

RELATED LINKS:
More High School Sports News

View Comments
  • http://Hockey.The-Art-Of.com/?p=9987 National Anthem Suggestion Stirs Controversy Among High School Hockey … – CBS Local | The Art Of Hockey

    [...] CBS Local [...]

  • http://www.conservativedailynews.com/2012/11/no-time-for-the-anthem/ No Time for the Anthem?

    [...] National Anthem should not be played only because of time constrains,” said  Sam, PA Interscholastic Hockey League commissioner. “It’s not that we’re not patriotic, that’s the [...]

  • http://www.alipac.us/f9/nearly-200-penn-high-school-hockey-teams-told-nix-playing-national-anthem-267080/#post1313224 Nearly 200 Penn. High School Hockey Teams Told to Nix Playing the National Anthem - ALIPAC

    [...] from sporting events? The league commissioner in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania apparently thinks so, suggesting a whopping 183 high school teams nix the few minutes it takes to honor the United States to [...]

  • http://newrepublicoftexas.com/news/nearly-200-penn-high-school-hockey-teams-told-to-nix-playing-the-national-anthem/ Nearly 200 Penn. High School Hockey Teams Told to Nix Playing the National Anthem |

    [...] league commissioner in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania apparently thinks so, suggesting a whopping 183 high school teams nix the few minutes it takes to honor the United States to [...]

  • http://www.stormfront.org/forum/t924984/#post10736152 200 high school hockey teams in Pennsylvania advised to eliminate the national anthem (takes too much time/money) – Stormfront

    [...] [...]

  • http://truefeminist.com/wp/world/2012/11/12/nearly-200-penn-high-school-hockey-teams-told-to-nix-playing-the-national-anthem/ NEARLY 200 PENN. HIGH SCHOOL HOCKEY TEAMS TOLD TO NIX PLAYING THE NATIONAL ANTHEM » TF World

    [...] league commissioner in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania apparently thinks so, suggesting a whopping 183 high school teams nix the few minutes it takes to honor the United States to [...]

  • http://sidewalkschalk.com/2012/11/12/no-national-anthem-told-pennsylvaina-high-school-hockey-teams/ NO National Anthem told Pennsylvaina High School Hockey Teams « Sidewalks Chalk

    [...] National Anthem Stirs Controversy Among High School Hockey Community [...]

  • http://www.tngovwatch.org/nearly-200-penn-high-school-hockey-teams-told-to-nix-playing-the-national-anthem/ Nearly 200 Penn. High School Hockey Teams Told to Nix Playing the National Anthem | Tennesseans Watching Federal & State Government

    [...] league commissioner in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania apparently thinks so, suggesting a whopping 183 high school teams nix the few minutes it takes to honor the United States to [...]

  • http://www.productionninja.com/?p=1062 Tues. Show Prep – America’s Funeral Edition « ProductionNinja.com

    [...] Starnes outrageous outrage of the day: High school hockey teams in Pennsylvania have been advised to drop the National Anthem from pregame …. Officials say it takes too much time to perform and costs too much money, since ice time is very [...]

  • http://nj1015.com/no-national-anthem-suggestion-outrages-high-school-hockey-community-is-it-un-american-poll/ No National Anthem Suggestion Outrages High School Hockey Community – Is it Un-American? [POLL]

    [...] According to this: [...]

  • http://pittsburgh.cbslocal.com/2012/11/13/hs-hockey-commissioner-has-change-of-heart-after-national-anthem-controversy/ HS Hockey Commissioner Has Change Of Heart After National Anthem Controversy « CBS Pittsburgh

    [...] LINKS: National Anthem Suggestion Stirs Controversy Among High School Hockey Community (11/9/12) More High School Sports News //// View Comments More Activity [...]

  • http://www.arpreport.com/pennsylvania-high-school-hockey-league-bans-national-anthem-to-save-money-on-ice-time/ Pennsylvania high school hockey league bans national anthem to save money on ice time | ArpReport

    [...] first reported by Pittsburgh CBS affiliate KDKA, the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Hockey League has issued a directive to 183 high school squads in central and western Pennsylvania banning the nationa… from being [...]

  • http://goldtent.org/?p=208884 Poster's Paradise » maybe we should get rid of the dunces who made this rule

    [...] not that we’re not patriotic, that’s the furthest from the truth,” commissioner Ed Sam told KDKA-TV, noting that ice time in the area costs around $300 an [...]

  • http://offthebench.nbcsports.com/2012/11/14/pa-hockey-league-dumps-national-anthem-because-it-takes-too-much-time-this-somehow-causes-controversy/ Pa. hockey league dumps National Anthem because it takes too much time … this somehow causes controversy | Off the Bench

    [...] Hockey League is discouraging its teams from playing the National Anthem before games, because it takes too much time. And as we know, time is [...]

  • http://www.forbes.com/sites/bobcook/2012/11/14/high-school-hockey-league-restores-national-anthem-hope-for-america/ High School Hockey League Restores National Anthem, Hope For America – Forbes

    [...] that PIHL, citing the high cost and low availability of ice time, cut out the national anthem in order to save a few minutes so games wouldn’t have to end early because the meter had run out. Though this might appear to be [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

TV Schedule

Full Program Grid
7:00 PM CBS Evening News with Scott Pelley
7:30 PM omg! Insider
8:00 PM The Big Bang Theory
8:31 PM Two and a Half Men
9:01 PM Person of Interest
10:01 PM Elementary
11:00 PM KDKA-TV News at 11
11:35 PM Late Show with David Letterman

Now On KDKA-TV:

follow us Now On KDKA TV: video on demand Now On KDKA TV: weatherbug small Now On KDKA TV: waitingchildsm Now On KDKA TV: ptls Now On KDKA TV: driving skills for l41d84c Now On KDKA TV:  Now On KDKA TV: heinzredzonerecipes3 Now On KDKA TV: hometownhighq Now On KDKA TV: 50261 pitts kdka local alleghenygeneralhospital extraeffort 140x85 2012 0817 Now On KDKA TV:

Select a Live Stream