KDKA 2 - Station Info KDKA News Radio 1020 - Station Info 93-7 The Fan - Station Info Pittsburgh-CW-Logo

Latest

Best Sandwich In The ‘Burgh

May 25, 2011 10:00 AM

View Comments
credit: www.primantibros.com
Pittsburgh is known for its delicious, French fry filled sandwiches and there’s no shortage of places to find that perfect sub or sandwich. Whether you’re looking for meats, cheeses or fish, we’ve got you covered. Here’s a look at some of our favorite sandwich spots.


Primanti Bros.

46 18th Street
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
412-263-2142

Oakland
3803 Forbes Avenue
Pittsburgh, PA 15213
412-621-4444

South Side
1832 East Carson Street
Pittsburgh, PA 15203
412-381-2583

Cherry Way
411 Cherry Way
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
412-566-8051

Market Square
2 South Market Square
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
412-261-1599

Come on, everyone knows about Primanti Bros. sandwiches! It’s the overwhelming favorite for locals and tourists! They’re the ones that start with grilled Italian bread, then are piled high with French fries and topped off with cole slaw. “Their cheesesteak classic is my favorite,” said a KDKA staffer.” In fact, in over 25 years of eating there, it’s all that I’ve ever ordered!” The original location is in the Strip District but the food is so fantastic it has grown to a string of successful stores. They’re found all over the metro area. “Pittsburgh’s famous sandwiches. Can’t beat ‘em!”

Smallman Street Deli

2840 Smallman Street
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
412-434-5800

Squirrel Hill Location
1912 Murray Avenue
Pittsburgh, PA 15217
412-421-3354

Smallman Street Deli is a Pittsburgh staple. It’s a full-service deli and catering company that can host parties up to 100 people (at the Squirrel Hill location). Menu items include: roasted chicken, grilled salmon, turkey and gravy and more. One KDKA staffer summed up the Smallman Street Deli like this: “Family owners. .. Great food… Great people.” It’s open for breakfast, lunch and dinner.

DiBella's Subs

1694 Rt. 228
Pittsburgh, PA
724-772-8088

Robinson Township
6501 Steubenville Pike
412-722-0443

Ahhh, DiBella’s Old Fashion Submarines. First, you’ll notice the freshly baked bread that accompanies each stacked sub. Their bread is baked all day long to ensure the freshest product. In fact, DiBella’s uses old-time baking techniques. Old fashion favorites include: turkey, ham, salami, capicola and a whole host of other meats and cheeses. If you’re feeling extra special, you can ask for peppers and onions, too. But, don’t forget the oil dressing! According to one KDKA employee, “Their sandwich oil is amazing!”

The Zenith

86 South 26th Street
Pittsburgh, PA 15203
412-481-4833

If you’re a veggie lover, don’t miss out on The Zenith in the city’s trendy South Side. It’s your spot for hummus, miso soup, tofu tacos and Middle Eastern stew. You can even try the “fish sandwich.” “It looks, smells, and even tastes like a breaded fish sandwich, but is made of “tofu!’ Even faked out my hubby!” said one of KDKA’s resident vegetarians. The Zenith also features a tea menu and a Sunday brunch menu.

Wholey

1711 Penn Avenue
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
412-391-3737

Wholey famous fish market is your one-stop shop for fish in the city. It began in the early 1900′s and has grown as a family business ever since. There are a lot of great places to get a fish sandwich in Pittsburgh, but some say none can compare to Wholey’s. “It’s gigantic and outstanding every time. Perfect with a little tartar sauce, but it can stand on its own!” said one KDKA fish-lover. Wholey features wild-caught, smoked fish, fillets and crab legs. You can even shop online! Enjoy!

Stoke's Grill

4771 McKnight Road
Pittsburgh, PA 15237
412-369-5380

Stoke’s Grill is located in the North Hills off of McKnight Road. If you’re looking for a good sandwich, look no further. Stoke’s features pretzel sandwiches packed with ham, roast beef, turkey and whatever else you like. It’s also known for its homemade meatballs and marinara as well as something called the “Hot Chix.” “Jason and Any have created something called “Hot Chix”, which is chicken, an original buffalo sauce and blue cheese,” said a KDKA staffer. Stoke’s Grill is known for its friendly efficiency and can handle parties of up to 250 people.

Fat Heads Saloon

1805 Carson Street
Pittsburgh, PA 15203
412-431-7433

Fat Heads is a unique experience! Located in the trendy South Side section of town, Fat Heads has a number of mouth watering sandwiches. “BIG Sandwiches & lots of choices. A favorite is the Beer Camp,” raves a KDKA staffer. They refer to some of their sandwiches as “headwiches” because, well, they’re the size of a human head. If you’re extra hungry, you can try the Cool Colossal Club or the Artery Clogger. Fat Heads is sure to satisfy even the hungriest customer.

Leo's Pub & Grille

202 North Diamond Street
Mount Pleasant, PA 15666
724-547-2006

Looking for a big selection of sandwiches? Leo’s Pub and Grill in Mount Pleasant is another KDKA favorite. “Extensive list of sandwiches and burgers… none will disappoint,” says a staffer. A crowd favorite is the Sicilian chicken salad with house dressing. Leo’s features over 40 homemade specialty burgers and if you need something to wash them down, they have 36 different beers on tap. Catering is also available.

Big Fellas

47 East Pike Street
Canonsburg, PA 15317
724-873-9222

If you’re ever south of the city and hungry for a sandwich that is a bit spicy but sure to please, then head to Big Fellas in Canonsburg in Washington County. It is located on the main drag through town and features an eatery and a smoke-free bar area. “The Southwest turkey sandwich is to die for. It is just spicy enough and leaves you full and satisfied,” says a KDKA turkey lover. This is also a great spot to get wings and pizza. The service is great and the prices are reasonable. “Definitely worth the trip.”

View Comments
  • Timbo

    Primantis may be the most overrated, overhyped, oversexed sandwich since the day the Earl of Sandwich put meat between sliced bread

    • jason

      primantis is the best you must not be a true pittsburgher

    • Charles

      Agreed.

    • Brenley

      It’s really great that people are sharing this infromaiotn.

  • joe

    Big Fellas is overated, and a bit pricey, i live in that town.

  • Judi Beu

    Primanti’s is AWESOME – truly is the BEST sandwich. But, the high calories means I can never get to eat it :-(

    DiBella’s is the best sub anywhere!! The DiBella’s cheesesteak is out of this world. Only one thing could make it better – mushrooms!!!

    • Jen Steberger

      Primanti’s doesn’t have a calorie count. I’m sure it’s probably comparable to a cheesesteak.

  • jackie

    The title of the article is: “Best Sandwich In The ‘Burgh” — and a hole-in-the-wall place in Mt. Pleasant is on the list?
    I’m not driving two hours away for a hole-in-the-wall sandwich.

    How about some REAL Pittsburgh (“burgh”) places…..there are plenty of great sandwich places INNNNNNNnnnn the Burgh! :) )))))

  • Rush Limbaughini

    Uncle Sams Subs rocks. You cant go wrong but i usually go with the italian.

  • Just Saying…

    “They’re the ones that start with grilled Italian bread…” Since when does Primanti’s grill their bread? How does a local news organization mess this up. If they can’t nail the easy facts why should we facts gathered through indepth investigation?

  • Val

    Uncle Sam’s Subs is AWESOME!!!!

  • PensFan58

    Im surprised Leo’s in Mt. Pleasant made this list, just because I didn’t think it was known around Pittsburgh. They have amazing fish sandwiches especially! probably 3 big crispy pieces of fish piled extra high on a hard bun. MMM!

  • Amanda

    Fiori’s didn’t make the list? I vote those best subs in the Burgh, really. Oh, and Dannys on Route 51 is great too

    • PA2VA

      I so love Danny’s and Fiori’s! Miss them so much here in VA!

  • T

    What about Peppi’s????

  • Dee

    The Real McCoy! A Southside Original! Haven’t been there? 2010 East Carson

  • Hoss

    The Triangle Bar and Grill in Swissvale deserves to be on the list. The Battleship sandwich rocks!

  • LivinInEF

    Love the Battleship (Corned Beef & Roast Beef)
    Just wear a flack jacket LOL…

  • Deeroy

    The triangle in the Vale. If you have never had it, and are up for an adventure the battleship is a must.

  • Chris vt

    Johnny’s on Craig Street has great teriyaki cheesesteak hoagie.

  • BJS

    Are we so desperate for “news” that we are rehasing an article from January? Or is this just a cheap advertisement from kdka?

  • Erik

    Real McCoy and Uncle Sams hands down

  • Lisa

    Try Beer Nutz in Aspinwall across from Atrias!

blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

TV Schedule

Full Program Grid
7:00 PM CBS Evening News with Scott Pelley
7:30 PM omg! Insider
8:00 PM NCIS: Los Angeles
9:00 PM NCIS
10:00 PM NCIS
11:00 PM KDKA-TV News at 11
11:35 PM Late Show with David Letterman

Now On KDKA-TV:

follow us Now On KDKA TV: video on demand Now On KDKA TV: weatherbug small Now On KDKA TV: waitingchildsm Now On KDKA TV: ptls Now On KDKA TV: driving skills for l41d84c Now On KDKA TV:  Now On KDKA TV: heinzredzonerecipes3 Now On KDKA TV: hometownhighq Now On KDKA TV: 50261 pitts kdka local alleghenygeneralhospital extraeffort 140x85 2012 0817 Now On KDKA TV:

Select a Live Stream